Müste’min Dealing with the Ottoman Justice: Role and Strategy of the Ambassador

Juliette Dumas (1, 2, 3)

1 IFEAGD - Institut français d'études anatoliennes - Georges Dumezil
2 IREMAM - Institut de Recherches et d'Etudes sur les Mondes Arabes et Musulmans
3 AMU ALLSH - Aix-Marseille Université - Faculté des Arts, Lettres, Langues et Sciences Humaines

Because of their status as foreigners, non-subject of the Empire, müsteʾmin are subject to a system of laws different from the other subjects of the Empire. They also benefit from advantages secured by the granting of imperial orders: the ʿahidnâme also known as the capitulations: these are prescriptions issued by the sultan, directly influenced by political and economic aspects and which may vary from one nation to another. However, it is not a code of law different from others in force in the Empire: except in specific cases prescribed by the capitulations, the müsteʾmin are submitted as other Ottoman subjects to the Ottoman legal system. Nevertheless, the Ottoman legal system is complex: the actors and the practices vary and depend on the individuals involved and cases. Therefore, the question is who are the interlocutors of the müsteʾmin? The documents examined here show that the type of conflicts impacted on the interlocutors that were involved. Each time the case involves, in one way or another, the privileges of the müsteʾmin from a given nation, the imperial divan had to solve the case-then, it usually refers to the local court. But if private, the case was directly submitted to the kadı. The call for submission of cases to the Imperial divan is interesting because it shows that confidence is put in the Imperial divan rather than in the kadı. Perhaps, it also reveals the limits of the legal knowledge of the privileges and the special rights granted to müsteʾmin. In fact, the population concerned by the Capitulations was minor and the affairs affecting them probably rare, as a result, one should not be surprised by the lack of knowledge of the local actors, of their privileges. The role of the embassy and of the ambassador must also be emphasized here. In our documents, it appears that the embassy as a whole played a significant role in supporting its citizens through legal advice, assistance and support. The French embassy even seems to have distinguished itself on this item since the legal support offered was presented by the ambassador.

Mots clés: Kadıs Court; Galata; Diplomacy; Müste'min; Zimmi; Trans-Imperial Subjects

Domaines: Histoire

Juliette Dumas. Müste’min Dealing with the Ottoman Justice: Role and Strategy of the Ambassador. Oriente Moderno, 2013, 93 (2), pp.477-494. ⟨10.1163/22138617-12340028⟩. ⟨hal-02116406⟩