Analytical aspects of measuring 2H/1H and 18O/16O ratios in urine from doubly labelled water studies by high- temperature conversion elemental analyser-isotope-ratio mass spectrometry
Résumé
RATIONALE: Total Body Water (TBW) and Total Energy Expenditure (TEE) are routinely measured in free-living
conditions by the 2H2
18O method. Isotope eliminations can be measured from spot urine samples by HTC-EA IRMS,
but only after cumbersome cryogenic distillation to extract water. Distillation may, however, be replaced by charcoal
treatment and filtration. This study tested (1) the effect of sample treatments (filtration versus distillation) on the isotope
ratios, (2) the effect of different ways of normalization that respect or not the principle of identical treatment of the
sample and references, and (3) the impact on the biological outcomes.
METHODS: Two filters (PES membrane; 10 kDa) accepting volumes of urine samples (V500: 0.5 mL versus V6: 3.0 mL)
were tested. In-house water standards and in-house urine standards were prepared and normalized against the
international scale to calibrate the urine samples. The δ2H and δ18O values from water in the urine were measured by
HTC-EA IRMS.
RESULTS: Filtered urine normalized with water standards showed a bias in the δ2H values that was corrected when
calibration was performed with urine standards. At a δ2H value of 1101.4 ‰, the accuracy increased from –11.9 to –0.2
δ‰ (V500) and from –3.8 to 0.4 δ‰ (V6). The TBW errors were greatest with V500 and water calibration (1.20 %) and
lowest with V6 and urine calibration (0.34 %; preparation-by-calibration interaction p = 0.027). For the δ18O values the
accuracy of enrichments and TBW were not affected whatever preparations and normalization were used. The average
TEE was not affected but the variability increased from 0.6 to 2.7 % versus cryogenic distillation.
CONCLUSIONS: Cryogenic distillation remains the gold standard for small sample size experiments where small
changes in TEE are to be detected. Filtration offers an alternative for large-scale experiments. When the body composition
is derived from 2H2O dilution, it is strongly recommended that urine standards should be used to eliminate the effect of
filtration. Copyright © 2015 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.