Manipulation-Proof Performance Measure and the Cost of Tail Risk

Didier Maillard (1)

1 LIRSA - Laboratoire interdisciplinaire de recherche en sciences de l'action

This paper builds on the seminal Goetzmann, Ingersoll, Spiegel and Welch research on Manipulation-Proof Performance Measures (MPPM), with a different purpose. Manipulation of usual performance measures generally goes through taking risk which is not reflected in the second moment measure of return distribution, variance or volatility. The MPPM corrects the impact of tail risk-negative skewness and kurtosis-taken by a fund manager (not necessarily with the explicit aim to manipulate the performance measures). In our paper, we try to quantify, using a Cornish Fisher technology allowing us to control for tail risk, the impact of such risk on the MPPM. In that framework, we find that the MPPM effectively does impose a penalty on tail risk. This penalty increases nearly linearly with return kurtosis and return negative skewness. The size of the penalty is rather benign when return volatility is low or the risk parameter is low. It increases substantially for high volatilities and/or high risk parameters.

Mots clés: JEL classification: C02; G11; G12; G21

Domaines: Sciences de l'Homme et Société

Didier Maillard. Manipulation-Proof Performance Measure and the Cost of Tail Risk. 2020. ⟨hal-02989192⟩