How The Simplification of Work Can Degrade Safety: A Gas Company Case Study

Hortense Blazsin (1) , Franck Guarnieri (1) , Christophe Martin (1)

1 CRC - Centre de recherche sur les Risques et les Crises

Work is focused on a gas company that wishes to develop a better understanding of its safety culture and identify potential enhancement opportunities. The hypothesis that emerged from an exploratory phase of work suggests that the corporate restructuring initiated four years ago, which has divided the company into distinct business units, has reduced organizational reliability. This issue raises a question faced by most industrial organizations, namely the trade-off between productivity and safety. On the one hand, streamlining activities offers an opportunity to save money, particularly through economies of scale and employee specialization. On the other hand maintaining flexibility generates costs, but provides a defence against silo effects, which are detrimental to safety. This paper describes how the company was restructured and the effects on risk management. The aim is to better understand the effects of the rationalisation on organizational reliability and performance, in order to identify potential solutions that may limit any counter-productive impacts.

Mots clés: Resilience; Safety Culture; Division of Activity; Organization; Field operators; Managers; Trade-Offs

Domaines: Gestion et management

Hortense Blazsin, Franck Guarnieri, Christophe Martin. How The Simplification of Work Can Degrade Safety: A Gas Company Case Study. 5th International Symposium on Resilience Engineering, Jun 2013, Netherlands. ⟨hal-00839473v2⟩