Area Study prior to Companion Modelling to Integrate Multiple Interests in Upper Watershed Management of Northern Thailand

Cécile Barnaud (1, 2) , Guy Trebuil (1) , Pongchai Dumrongrojwatthana (3) , Jérôme Marie (2)

1 UPR GREEN - Gestion des ressources renouvelables et environnement
2 GECKO - Laboratoire de Géographie Comparée des Suds et des Nords
3 Chulalongkorn University [Bangkok]

Ethnic minorities living in the highlands of northern Thailand have long been accused of degrading the upper watersheds of the country's major basins. In the nineties, the government reinforced his environmental policies and further restricted their access to farm and forest resources. In the meanwhile, the policy framework also favoured decentralization and public participation. This contradiction resulted in an increasing number of conflicts over land-use between local communities and state agencies, calling for the need for adapted participatory methodologies to facilitate coordination among multiple stakeholders with competing interests. Companion Modelling (ComMod) is one of them. When drawing the lessons from many past participatory projects, several authors highlight their limited impact due to the lack of support at higher institutional levels. Moreover, because of a lack of attention to the local socio-political situations, the less powerful stakeholders were often left behind. This article discusses the usefulness of an area diagnostic study prior to the launch of a ComMod process to avoid such pitfalls and to facilitate genuine communication among stakeholders within and across institutional levels. The article is illustrated by a ComMod experiment conducted in Nan province and focusing on a conflict between two Yao communities and a recently established National Park. We suggest that a relatively short but well-structured initial agrarian and institutional analysis to assess the various stakeholders' characteristics, perceptions of the issue to be solved, and interactions is useful to identify the constraints to an equitable outcome of a subsequent participatory process. It is also used to adapt the ComMod process in order to mitigate these constraints. Moreover, such a picture of the initial situation is necessary to assess the effects of the following participatory process.

Domaines: Géographie

Cécile Barnaud, Guy Trebuil, Pongchai Dumrongrojwatthana, Jérôme Marie. Area Study prior to Companion Modelling to Integrate Multiple Interests in Upper Watershed Management of Northern Thailand. Southeast Asian Studies, 2008, 45 (4), pp.559-585. ⟨hal-00609635⟩