Biodiversity and pest management in orchard systems. A review

Sylvaine Simon , Jean-Charles Bouvier , Jean-François Debras , Benoît Sauphanor

Conventional agriculture is based on a high level of chemical inputs such as pesticides and fertilisers, leading to serious environmental impacts, health risks and loss of biodiversity in agrosystems. The reduction of pesticide use is a priority for intensively sprayed agricultural systems such as orchards. The preservation and promotion of biodiversity within orchards and their boundaries is therefore an issue to explore. Indeed, orchard systems contain high plant diversity and perennial multi-strata designs that provide wealthy resources and habitats to living communities such as beneficial organisms. Orchards thus offer favourable areas to maintain food-webs within the agrosystem, provided that favourable situations are not altered by cultural practices such as applying an excess of pesticides. Here, we analysed literature on the effects of the manipulation of plant diversity and habitats on the control of pests by arthropod and bird communities in apple, pear and peach orchards. Many investigations focus on the role of plant management to enhance biodiversity in orchards but only 22 research reports presenting 30 case studies were dedicated to the study of the ecosystem service provided by plant diversity for orchard pest control. The underlying mechanisms were seldom demonstrated, and the tested grass covers and tree assemblages aimed at favouring either the beneficial complex or only some beneficial species to control one or a few pests. The effect of plant management on pest control was mostly positive (16 cases) or null (9), but also negative in some cases (5). This finding reveals the difficulties of identifying selected plants or plant assemblages for the control of key pests. We conclude that further research is needed to identify the processes involved on different scales for biological control. Orchard systems should be re-designed to optimise ecosystem services provided by biodiversity.

Mots clés: biodiversity; orchard; fruit tree; plant; arthropod; bird; community; pest management; hedgerow; plant cover

Domaines: Sciences agricoles; Ecologie, Environnement

Sylvaine Simon, Jean-Charles Bouvier, Jean-François Debras, Benoît Sauphanor. Biodiversity and pest management in orchard systems. A review. Agronomy for Sustainable Development, 2010, 30 (1), pp.139-152. ⟨10.1051/agro/2009013⟩. ⟨hal-00886515⟩