Computing Inconsistency Measure based on Paraconsistent Semantics

Yue Ma (1) , Guilin Qi (2) , Pascal Hitzler (3)

1 LIPN - Laboratoire d'Informatique de Paris-Nord
2 School of Computer Science and Engineering, Southeast University
3 Kno.e.sis Center, Wright State University, Dayton, OH,USA

Measuring inconsistency in knowledge bases has been recog- nized as an important problem in several research areas. Many methods have been proposed to solve this problem and a main class of them is based on some kind of paraconsistent semantics. However, existing methods suffer from two limitations: 1) They are mostly restricted to propositional knowledge bases; 2) Very few of them discuss computational aspects of computing inconsistency measures. In this paper, we try to solve these two limitations by exploring algorithms for computing an inconsistency measure of first-order knowledge bases. After introducing a four-valued semantics for first-order logic, we define an inconsistency measure of a first-order knowledge base, which is a sequence of inconsistency degrees. We then propose a precise algorithm to compute our inconsistency measure. We show that this algorithm reduces the computation of the inconsistency measure to classical satisfiability checking. This is done by introducing a new semantics, named S[n]-4 semantics, which can be calculated by invoking a classical SAT solver. Moreover, we show that this auxiliary semantics also gives a direct way to compute upper and lower bounds of inconsistency degrees. That is, it can be easily revised to compute approximating inconsistency measures. The approximating inconsistency measures converge to the precise values if enough resources are available. Finally, by some nice properties of the S[n]-4 semantics, we show that some upper and lower bounds can be computed in P-time, which says that the problem of computing these approximating inconsistency measures is tractable.

Domaines: Intelligence artificielle [cs.AI]

Yue Ma, Guilin Qi, Pascal Hitzler. Computing Inconsistency Measure based on Paraconsistent Semantics. Journal of Logic and Computation, 2010, pp.1257-1281. ⟨hal-00528921⟩