submit
english version rss feed
HAL: hal-00477759, version 1

Detailed view  Export this paper
Crises et nouvelles problématiques de la Valeur, Nice : France (2010)
KEEPING ACCOUNTS BY THE BOOK: THE REVELATION(S) OF ACCOUNTING
Vassili Joannides 1, Nicolas Berland 2
(2010)

Our paper addresses what the moral foundations of accounting are, regardless of capitalistic operations, as we are seeking to trace a genealogy of accounting thinking disconnected from coincidence with Capitalism. We demonstrate that the three monotheisms have bared the core of accounting. We purport to explicate how the three monotheisms (Judaism, Christianity divided into Roman Catholicism and Protestantisms, and Islam) have successively revealed the nature of accounting to moralise people's day-to-day conduct. Our approach to the revelation of accounting is informed with practice theory to study how accounting was used in believers' day-today activities and faith management. To this end, we read theological debates on accounting from Rabbinic, Islamic, Catholic and Protestant literatures raised at the time of the Reformation. Our study reveals that, in the four religions, bookkeeping serves as routine and rules to account for daily conduct, its content being contingent upon common understandings (viz. God's identity, capabilities and expectations) and teleoaffective structures (viz. definition of and ways to salvation). Through this paper, we demonstrate that accounting issues have always served as a sub-practice in moral practices and is therefore not necessarily coincidental with economic operations. Ultimately, we contribute to literature on the genesis of accounting, accounting as situated practice and accounting as moral practice.day-today activities and faith management. To this end, we read theological debates on accounting from Rabbinic, Islamic, Catholic and Protestant literatures raised at the time of the Reformation. Our study reveals that, in the four religions, bookkeeping serves as routine and rules to account for daily conduct, its content being contingent upon common understandings (viz. God's identity, capabilities and expectations) and teleoaffective structures (viz. definition of and ways to salvation). Through this paper, we demonstrate that accounting issues have always served as a sub-practice in moral practices and is therefore not necessarily coincidental with economic operations. Ultimately, we contribute to literature on the genesis of accounting, accounting as situated practice and accounting as moral practice.
1:  Gestion, Droit et Finance (GDF)
Grenoble Ecole de Management
2:  Dauphine Recherches en Management (DRM)
CNRS : UMR7088 – Université Paris IX - Paris Dauphine
Humanities and Social Sciences/Business administration
religion – accounting – Catholicism – Protestantism – Judaism – Islam – Control as practice
Attached file list to this document: 
PDF
p44.pdf(212.8 KB)

all articles on CCSd database...
all articles on CCSd database...
all articles on CCSd database...
all articles on CCSd database...
all articles on CCSd database...
all articles on CCSd database...
all articles on CCSd database...
all articles on CCSd database...
all articles on CCSd database...
all articles on CCSd database...
all articles on CCSd database...
all articles on CCSd database...
all articles on CCSd database...
all articles on CCSd database...
all articles on CCSd database...
all articles on CCSd database...
all articles on CCSd database...
all articles on CCSd database...
all articles on CCSd database...